Chapter 4 - The Outlaw's Kitchen Table
My hands shook so violently that it took me three attempts to jam the ignition key into my battered station wagon.
I peeled out of the municipal lot without headlights, turning into the dark alleyway behind the lumber yard.
In my rearview mirror, red and blue strobe lights painted the brick facade of Town Hall as Vance's cruiser gave chase to the motorcycle.
I drove in circles for fifteen minutes, checking every intersection to ensure no secondary deputy cruisers were trailing me.
My mother was watching Emma for the night at her farmhouse five miles outside county lines, thank God.
My daughter was safe, but my home was no longer secure; Vance would check my townhouse within the hour.
There was only one place in this valley where Thomas Vance could not walk without a warrant and a dozen armed backup deputies.
I drove out toward the county line, past the abandoned limestone quarry, and turned onto an unpaved gravel lane overgrown with wild sumac.
At the end of the lane stood an old cinderblock workshop surrounded by rusty iron frames and overgrown blackberry briars.
A single naked lightbulb burned over a rusted corrugated tin garage door.
Parked just inside the open bay was a mud-splattered black Harley-Davidson, its twin exhaust pipes still ticking as the metal cooled.
I killed my engine, stepped out into the gravel, and pulled my jacket tight against the biting mountain wind.
The shadows inside the garage shifted, and Marcus Miller stepped into the faint yellow light.
He was wearing the same scuffed leather cut, but in his right hand, he held a heavy iron crowbar, his knuckles pale and raw.
"You got a lot of nerve driving down my road at midnight, lady," Marcus rumbled, his chest rising and falling in heavy, ragged intervals.
"You were the one on the motorcycle at Town Hall," I said, my voice steady despite my hammering heart.
"You broke the basement window."
Marcus lowered the crowbar an inch, his swollen eyes narrowing as he recognized my face under the security bulb.
"The little girl’s mother," he murmured, his posture slumping slightly.
"You were in the archives. I saw your car parked behind the maintenance shed when I rode by to spit on that building."
"Why did you throw that brick, Marcus?" I asked, stepping closer to the concrete threshold.
"Because I saw Vance’s squad car pull in with his running lights off," Marcus replied, spitting into the weeds.
"Thomas Vance doesn't kill his headlights unless he’s fixing to put a beating on somebody or bury something in the woods."
He turned and walked deeper into the garage, gesturing for me to follow him inside.
The workshop smelled of 90-weight gear oil, woodsmoke, and stale coffee.
In the back corner was a small living quarter partitioned off by cheap plywood—a single cot, a cast-iron stove, and a laminate table.
Pinned to the plywood wall were dozens of newspaper clippings, faded maps, and photographs of Sarah at every age of her childhood.
Sitting on the edge of the grease-stained table was Emma’s squished red gummy bear, resting carefully on top of a clean white napkin.
"Sit down," Marcus said, setting the crowbar against the woodstove and dragging a rusted metal stool toward me.
I pulled the brittle DPW carbon sheet from inside my jacket and laid it out flat on the table right next to the red candy.
Marcus stared at the blue carbon print, his massive shoulders tensing until his neck tendons stood out like thick cords.
"What is this?" he asked, not touching the paper.
"It’s the tow log from October 14, 2004," I said, pointing to the scrawled handwriting at the bottom.
"Arthur Pendelton, the old bus driver, saw an unmarked blue sedan parked at the pavilion when your daughter disappeared."
"Arthur died of a stroke eight months after Sarah vanished," Marcus whispered, his voice cracking down the middle.
"He told the deputies he didn't see anything out of the ordinary."
"He lied to the deputies, or the deputies altered his sworn statement," I countered, tapping the carbon ink.
"Look at the tow time: 8:30 AM. Thomas Vance personally signed off on towing a midnight blue Ford Crown Victoria from the quarry road."
Marcus leaned forward, his massive palms flattening on the table with enough force to make the wood frame groan.
"That wasn't a civilian car," Marcus growled, his bloodshot eyes blazing with an unholy fire.
"In 2004, the only person in this whole damned county who drove a midnight blue Crown Vic was Sheriff Donald Vance."
"Thomas Vance’s father," I said, the horrifying realization settling into my gut like lead.
"Old Donald," Marcus whispered, his entire body beginning to shake with the same gut-wrenching fury I had seen at the playground.
"He ran the department like his personal fiefdom. Thomas was just his little errand boy back then."
Marcus reached up and grabbed his own beard, pulling at the whiskers as twenty-two years of suffocating confusion snapped into focus.
"They told me Sarah ran away because of me," he wept, the tears carving fresh tracks through the grease on his cheeks.
"They told the whole valley I was a drunk who beat his kid until she took off for California."
"The town believed them because Donald Vance held every mortgage and every criminal record in his back pocket," I said.
Marcus looked up at me, his eyes wide with a terrifying mix of grief and vengeance.
"Where is the car, Clara? If Donald Vance killed my girl or covered it up, that Crown Vic didn't just vanish into thin air."
I looked back down at the yellowed carbon receipt, reading the destination line at the bottom.
The vehicle had not been taken to the county impound lot on Highway 9.
It had been routed to Lot 4, Vance & Sons Salvage - North Yard Crane.
"Ray Vance’s old junkyard," I said softly.
"The place caught fire in 2008 and was abandoned after the EPA declared it a hazardous soil site."
Marcus stood up to his full six-foot-four height, reaching for the heavy crowbar resting against the cast-iron stove.
"The North Yard has an old industrial car crusher that sat on a concrete slab near the back creek," Marcus said, his voice deadly calm.
"If they crushed that blue sedan, the metal block is still sitting under twenty years of scrap iron."
Outside the garage, the faint, distant whine of a county police siren echoed across the timber ridge.
Thomas Vance had not caught the motorcycle; he was casting a wider net, and my station wagon was registered to this district.
"You can't go down there with a crowbar, Marcus," I said, standing up to block his path.
"Vance is hunting both of us now. If you show up with a weapon, he will shoot you dead and call it justifiable defense."
Marcus looked down at me, his gaze dropping to the little red gummy bear resting peacefully on the white paper napkin.
May you like
"Your little girl gave me this candy because she thought my heart hurt," Marcus said, his gravelly voice dropping to a raw whisper.
"My heart has been dead for twenty-two years, Clara. Tonight, I'm going to find my daughter's bones, or Thomas Vance is going to have to put a bullet through my skull."
