Chapter 8 - The Arraignment of Monsters
The following morning at nine o’clock, the grand wood-paneled courtroom of the Fifth District Municipal Court was packed to capacity.
Local journalists, drawn by rumors of a massive financial and domestic abuse scandal in the wealthy suburbs, filled the rear benches.
I sat in the front row of the gallery, flanked by Marcus Hayes and Sarah Jenkins, watching the heavy security door beside the bench swing open.
Two armed bailiffs escorted my mother, Selina Vance, into the courtroom through the prisoner transit corridor.
The transformation in her appearance over forty-eight hours was staggering.
The polished, aristocratic matriarch who had worn cashmere and pearls on the patio was completely gone.
She was dressed in a baggy, bright orange county jail jumpsuit, her feet shuffling in orange rubber slippers chained together at the ankles.
Her salon-styled silver hair was disheveled and unwashed, hanging in limp strands around a face that looked fifty years older.
Her wrists were bound by heavy nickel handcuffs connected to a belly chain that clanked with every agonizing step she took.
She kept her head down, avoiding the flashbulbs of the press cameras, her pride completely shattered beneath the weight of public humiliation.
Sitting behind her defense attorney’s table, her privately appointed public defender shuffled through a thin stack of preliminary motions.
Godfrey was not in the prisoner dock; he had managed to post five thousand dollars cash bond the previous night on his initial trespassing citation.
He was sitting four rows behind me in the gallery, wearing an ill-fitting civilian suit, chewing his fingernails until they bled.
He had no idea that Detective Vance was standing by the double wooden doors at the back of the room, flanked by two plainclothes state troopers.
Judge Evelyn Vance-Cross—a renowned, no-nonsense jurist with a reputation for mercilessly punishing elder and dependent abuse—took the bench.
The gavel struck the mahogany sounding block with a single, sharp crack that commanded instant, pin-drop silence throughout the chamber.
“State of Ohio versus Selina Vance, Case Number 24-CR-8902,” the court clerk announced clearly.
“Charges: felony attempted murder by deprivation, aggravated dependent abuse, first-degree grand larceny, and twelve counts of felony forgery,” the clerk read.
Selina’s defense counsel, a weary-looking attorney named Richard Sterling, stepped up to the podium with a prepared memorandum.
“Your Honor, we are petitioning for immediate release on personal recognizance or an unsecured signature bond,” Sterling began smoothly.
“My client is a sixty-four-year-old grandmother with no prior criminal record and deep roots in this municipal community,” Sterling argued.
“She suffers from chronic hypertension and mild degenerative joint disease, making detention in the county jail a grave health risk,” the lawyer claimed.
“Furthermore, this entire matter stems from a tragic, mismanaged family dynamic involving a terminally ill dependent,” Sterling added.
Judge Vance-Cross looked over the rim of her reading glasses, her gaze colder than dry ice.
“The State may respond,” the judge commanded, turning her pen toward the lead prosecutor.
District Attorney Catherine Bell stepped to the prosecution podium, carrying a thick binder and an electronic presentation tablet.
“Your Honor, the State moves for absolute remand without bail,” DA Bell declared, her voice ringing clear throughout the courtroom.
“This is not a tragic family misunderstanding; this is an attempted cold-blooded execution executed for financial profit,” DA Bell stated.
The prosecutor tapped her tablet, and the two massive monitors mounted on the courtroom walls lit up with high-resolution photographs.
The entire courtroom gasped in collective horror.
The screens displayed the inside of the uninsulated aluminum tool shed: the rusted cot, the frozen mud floor, and the cracked plastic bucket.
Beside it was a photograph of Phoebe taken at triage: seventy-nine pounds, bald, covered in pressure sores, and bruised from head to toe.
Selina squeezed her eyes shut, unable to look at the undeniable evidence of her sadistic cruelty displayed before the public.
“For eleven months, the defendant intercepted sixty-four thousand dollars in specialized chemotherapy infusions,” DA Bell continued relentlessly.
“She stashed them behind designer fur coats in her closet while watching her daughter-in-law starve in freezing temperatures,” the prosecutor said.
“And yesterday evening, during the execution of a supplemental search warrant, law enforcement recovered an active life insurance contract,” DA Bell revealed.
The courtroom erupted into a low murmur of shock as the policy schedule flashed across the digital monitors.
“A seven-hundred-and-fifty-thousand-dollar policy, with an accidental death multiplier yielding one point five million dollars,” DA Bell stated.
“Issued to Apex Horizon Holdings LLC—a shell corporation formed by the defendant and her co-conspirator son, Godfrey Vance,” the prosecutor added.
Godfrey froze in the gallery behind me, his breath catching in his throat as every head in the courtroom whipped around to stare at him.
His eyes darted frantically toward the exit, but Detective Vance and the two state troopers were already blocking the aisle.
“The defendant poses an extraordinary danger to the surviving victim and represents an extreme flight risk,” DA Bell concluded.
“The State requests that Selina Vance be held without bond pending trial,” the prosecutor demanded.
Judge Vance-Cross removed her glasses and set them down on the bench, leaning forward with an expression of profound disgust.
“In my twenty-two years on this bench, I have rarely encountered evidence demonstrating such calculated, depraved indifference to human life,” Judge Vance-Cross stated.
“You treated a dying woman with less compassion than a civilized society shows to a rabid stray,” the judge reprimanded the trembling woman in orange.
“The defense motion for bail is denied in its entirety,” Judge Vance-Cross ruled, striking her gavel down.
“The defendant, Selina Vance, is remanded to the maximum-security custody of the county sheriff without bond,” she ordered.
Selina collapsed forward onto the defense table, sobbing hysterically as the bailiffs grabbed her by the arms and pulled her backward.
“Damian! Tell them to stop! I’m your mother! You can’t let them lock me away!” Selina wailed, thrashing against her chains.
“I did it for the family! I did everything for you, Damian!” she shrieked until the heavy steel transit door slammed shut behind her.
Before the courtroom could clear, DA Bell stepped forward once more, raising a fresh legal document sealed with a red wax stamp.
“Your Honor, the State has a supplemental matter regarding an unsealed grand jury indictment returned thirty minutes ago,” DA Bell announced.
“The grand jury has returned an indictment against Godfrey Vance for conspiracy to commit aggravated murder and money laundering,” the prosecutor read.
Godfrey let out a choked shriek of terror, jumping out of his gallery seat and scrambling toward the side exit.
“I didn't do it! Mom planned the whole thing! It was all her idea!” Godfrey screamed, knocking over a wooden spectator bench.
Detective Vance stepped into his path, sweeping Godfrey’s legs out from under him with a textbook tackle that slammed him onto the carpet.
The two state troopers pinned his arms behind his back, the sharp metallic click of handcuffs snapping shut across his trembling wrists.
“Godfrey Vance, you are under arrest pursuant to an indictment of the grand jury,” Detective Vance recited into his ear.
Godfrey thrashed and sobbed on the floor, his designer suit covered in carpet lint and dirt, his face red with tears and snot.
“Damian! Help me! Call Marcus! You have the settlement money, just buy me a lawyer!” Godfrey begged, looking up at me from the floor.
I stood above him, looking down into the eyes of the brother who had toasted his scotch over my wife’s starving body.
May you like
“You spent your lawyer money on that truck, Godfrey,” I said quietly.
“And unlike Phoebe,” I added, turning toward the double doors, “you’re going to get three hot meals a day in the cage you built for yourself.”
