Chapter 2 - The Ghost at the Head of the Table
I set the chipped white plate down on the corner of the polished mahogany table.
Thirty pairs of eyes watched my hands as I picked up a heavy silver dessert knife.
My fingers were trembling slightly, but I pressed the blade firmly down through the lopsided sponge.
The crust was slightly overcooked and resisted the knife for half a second.
Then the blade sank into the rich, dense crumb beneath.
A distinct, unmistakable aroma escaped into the cool air of the dining room.
Fresh Meyer lemon zest.
Tangy sour cream.
Pure Madagascar vanilla.
And the distinct, buttery richness of a recipe that belonged to a woman who had been gone for five long years.
I lifted the first slice onto an antique bone china plate.
It was not an elegant cut.
The yellow frosting smeared across the edge of the plate, and a shower of moist yellow crumbs broke off against the gold rim.
Vanessa let out a small, disgusted sound under her breath and crossed her arms tightly over her chest.
Luca didn’t wait for a napkin.
He picked up his sterling silver fork, his large hand moving with deliberate precision.
He sliced off the tip of the cake, gathering a dollop of the crooked yellow frosting, and placed it into his mouth.
For five agonizing seconds, nobody in the grand room took a breath.
Luca stopped chewing.
His entire body stiffened as if an electric charge had surged straight through his spine.
His dark eyes widened by a fraction of a millimeter.
He lowered his fork slowly to the table until the metal clinked against the china.
He closed his eyes.
The ruthless mafia boss who had executed three traitors in an industrial warehouse last Tuesday suddenly looked like a drowning man grasping for air.
When he opened his eyes again, they were glossy with unshed tears.
His voice came out in a low, gravelly rasp that vibrated across the entire length of the table.
“Where did you get this recipe?”
Vanessa immediately leaned in, placing her manicured hand over his clenched fist.
“Luca, darling, it’s just basic pound cake with lemon extract.”
“The housekeeper probably pulled it off the internet to make some cheap display.”
Luca didn’t even flinch.
He didn’t look at Vanessa.
He didn’t move his hand to comfort hers.
He looked directly into my eyes, searching for the truth with terrifying intensity.
“Claire. Tell me right now.”
“Who made this cake?”
I took a deep, steadying breath.
“Your daughter made it, Mr. Moretti.”
The room seemed to shrink.
The lieutenants and capos at the table shifted uncomfortably in their seats.
“Lily made this?” Luca asked, his voice barely above a whisper.
“Yes, sir.”
“All by herself?”
“I helped her turn on the oven and measure the sour cream, sir,” I replied honestly.
“Every other ingredient was measured by Lily’s own hands.”
“She frosted it herself.”
“She wrote those words on top herself.”
Luca stared down at the half-eaten slice on his plate.
“This is Sarah’s cake.”
It wasn’t a question.
It was a statement of absolute, undeniable fact.
“This is the exact cake Sarah baked the night we brought Lily home from Northwestern Memorial Hospital.”
“This is the cake she baked the night I took over the family business.”
He looked up, his gaze suddenly scanning the empty expanse of the dining room.
“Where is my daughter?”
Vanessa cleared her throat, attempting to regain control of the room with an elegant smile.
“Darling, as I already explained, Lily wasn’t feeling well.”
“She had a fever.”
“She was coughing.”
“I had Claire take her up to her room so she could get some much-needed sleep before tomorrow.”
I looked Vanessa dead in the eyes.
“That is a lie, Mr. Moretti.”
A collective gasp echoed down the long table.
Two capos leaned forward, shocked that a simple servant would dare call the daughter of Don Bellini a liar in front of the entire Chicago underworld.
Vanessa’s face turned from pale porcelain to a furious, blotchy crimson.
She stood up so fast her heavy mahogany chair screeched against the marble floor.
“You insolent, lying little gutter rat!” Vanessa screamed, abandoning all pretense of high-society elegance.
“How dare you speak to me like that in front of our guests!”
“Luca, fire her this instant!”
“Have Marco drag her down to the gate and throw her into the street!”
Luca didn't shout.
He didn't raise his voice.
He simply lifted his right hand, two fingers extended.
The entire dining room instantly froze into stone.
Even Vanessa choked on her next insult, her mouth hanging open in furious disbelief.
Luca turned his head slowly toward me.
“Claire.”
“Yes, sir?”
“Where is Lily?”
“She is downstairs in the basement pantry, Mr. Moretti.”
Luca’s eyes narrowed into slits.
“Why is my child in the pantry?”
“Because Miss Bellini told her she was a disgrace to this family.”
“Because Miss Bellini told her that Sarah is dead and buried, and that no one wants a dead woman’s memory ruining her engagement.”
“Because Miss Bellini threatened to have me fired if Lily was allowed upstairs before the guests left.”
Vanessa’s chest was heaving with fury.
“She is making this up, Luca!”
“She is an unstable, manipulative maid trying to extort money from you!”
“Ask anyone in the kitchen!”
Luca ignored her completely.
He kept his gaze locked onto mine.
“Go get my daughter, Claire.”
“Bring her to me right now.”
I didn’t wait for Vanessa to protest.
I turned on my heel and walked out through the swinging service doors.
I hurried down the narrow, dimly lit service stairs that led to the cold basement level.
The basement smelled of damp concrete, old wine racks, and industrial cleaning supplies.
At the very end of the hall was the walk-in pantry, its heavy wooden door pushed half-shut.
I pushed the door open.
The single bare lightbulb hanging from the ceiling cast harsh, yellow shadows across the metal wire shelves.
Lily was still sitting on an upside-down wooden apple crate tucked between sacks of flour and bulk canned tomatoes.
Her small knees were pulled tightly against her chest.
She looked up when the door creaked, her pale face streaked with tears and gray kitchen grime.
When she saw me, her lower lip began to tremble violently.
“Claire?” she whispered, her voice tiny and terrified.
“Is Daddy really mad at me?”
“Did he hate the cake?”
“Did I ruin his party?”
My heart broke into a thousand jagged pieces.
I walked over to the crate and knelt down in front of her, taking her cold, trembling little hands into mine.
“No, sweetheart.”
“Your daddy doesn’t hate the cake.”
“He ate it, and he loved it.”
“He loved it so much that he wants you upstairs right now.”
Lily pulled back slightly, her eyes wide with fear.
“But Vanessa said... she said if I came upstairs, she would make Daddy send me away to boarding school in Switzerland.”
I squeezed her hands firmly, looking directly into her fearful green eyes.
“Your father loves you more than this entire city, Lily.”
“Nobody is sending you anywhere.”
“Now stand up, smooth down your dress, and come with me.”
Lily stood up on shaky legs.
She wiped her eyes with the back of her flour-covered hand, smearing more white powder across her forehead.
She reached out and gripped my fingers with a strength that surprised me.
Together, we walked up the cold basement stairs.
We pushed through the double service doors and entered the brilliant, blinding light of the grand dining room.
The moment thirty pairs of eyes turned toward the doorway, Lily froze.
She gripped my apron tightly, trying to hide behind my skirt.
Luca Moretti had not sat back down.
He was standing at the head of the table, his tall silhouette framed against the floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking Lake Michigan.
The moment his eyes found Lily in her stained blue dress and flour-dusted hair, his cold, terrifying aura shattered.
“Lily,” he breathed.
He didn't care about his bespoke Italian suit.
He didn't care about the thirty powerful mafia capos watching him.
He dropped down onto both knees right on the hard marble floor in the center of the room.
He opened his arms wide.
“Come here, baby.”
Lily hesitated for half a second.
Then a tiny sob broke from her chest, and she sprinted across the dining room floor as fast as her small legs could carry her.
She threw herself into her father’s chest.
Luca caught her, wrapping his massive, scarred arms around her small frame and lifting her clean off the floor.
He buried his face into the crook of her neck, breathing in the scent of her hair.
“I’m sorry, Daddy,” Lily wept into his tuxedo jacket.
“I’m so sorry the cake was crooked.”
“I didn't mean to make it look ugly.”
“I just wanted to make Mom’s cake so we could celebrate.”
Luca’s shoulders trembled slightly as he held her tighter against his heart.
“It wasn’t ugly, baby.”
“It was the most beautiful thing I have ever seen.”
“I wouldn’t care if that cake was dropped on the floor and stepped on.”
“It’s the best thing I’ve tasted in five years.”
A tiny, watery giggle escaped Lily’s lips, followed by another wave of heavy tears.
Luca slowly pulled back, his large hands gently framing her tear-stained cheeks.
He wiped away the flour from her nose with his thumb.
“Tell me what happened, Lily.”
“Why were you sitting in the dark downstairs?”
Lily sniffled, her green eyes darting nervously toward Vanessa, who stood rigidly beside the banquet table.
“Vanessa came into the kitchen when we finished frosting it.”
“She said... she said that Mom was dead.”
“She said Mom had her turn, and that tonight we weren't allowed to drag dead people into the room.”
“She said after you get married, we have to stop doing Mom things forever.”
The silence in the dining room became suffocating.
Even the catering staff standing near the back walls looked horrified.
Luca didn't look at Vanessa yet.
He kept his eyes locked on his daughter’s face.
“Did she say anything else, Lily?”
Lily reached into the deep pocket of her pale blue dress.
Her small fingers pulled out a crumpled, dirty piece of paper.
She handed it to her father.
Luca looked down at his open palm.
It was the vintage index card containing Sarah Moretti’s lemon cake recipe.
Except it was no longer in one piece.
The card had been violently torn straight down the center.
Sarah’s elegant handwriting was ripped in half.
Luca stared at the two jagged pieces of paper resting in his palm.
His thumb traced the torn edge where his late wife’s signature had been severed.
When he finally lifted his head, the warmth in his eyes had vanished entirely.
What remained was something ancient, merciless, and terrifyingly cold.
He looked directly at Vanessa Bellini.
“Did you tear this?” Luca asked.
His voice was dangerously quiet.
Vanessa swallowed hard, but she refused to back down in front of her father’s business associates.
“For God’s sake, Luca! It’s a five-cent piece of cardboard!”
“We are about to merge the two most powerful families in the state!”
“And you are kneeling on the floor making a scene over a dirty scrap of paper!”
Luca slowly rose from the floor, keeping Lily securely balanced on his hip with one arm.
“This isn't a piece of paper, Vanessa.”
“This is my daughter’s last piece of her mother.”
Vanessa scoffed, tossing her hair over her shoulder.
“And where does that leave me, Luca?”
“Am I supposed to live in this house as a ghost, walking in Sarah’s shadow for the rest of my life?”
“Every single room is a monument to her!”
“Every time we try to move forward, this child drags out another relic from the grave!”
Lily flinched, burying her face into her father’s neck to hide her tears.
Luca tightened his grip on his daughter, his eyes turning to black ice.
“My daughter is allowed to remember her mother every single second of every single day.”
“If you cannot accept that, Vanessa, then you will never be welcome across that threshold.”
Vanessa’s jaw dropped.
Murmurs broke out among the guests at the table.
Canceling an alliance between the Moretti and Bellini syndicates was tantamount to declaring open war in the streets of Chicago.
Before Vanessa could speak, Lily tugged gently on the lapel of her father’s jacket.
“Daddy?” Lily whispered.
Luca looked down at her, his expression softening instantly.
“Yes, baby?”
“Can you please make Vanessa give back Mom’s cedar box?”
Luca’s eyebrows knitted together in confusion.
“What do you mean, give it back?”
Lily’s eyes welled with fresh tears.
“Mom’s recipe box from the pantry cabinet.”
“The one with all her handwritten notes and the letters she wrote to me before she got sick.”
“Vanessa took it this afternoon.”
The color drained from Luca Moretti’s face with terrifying speed.
“When did she take it, Lily?”
“Right after she sent me downstairs.”
“I saw her carrying it out toward the back.”
Luca turned his head toward Vanessa, his gaze heavy enough to crush bone.
“Where is Sarah’s recipe box, Vanessa?”
Vanessa reached for her champagne glass with trembling fingers, taking a long, desperate sip before setting it down.
“I... I simply put it away, Luca.”
“I was redecorating the pantry for our new private chef.”
“Where did you put it?” Luca stepped toward her, his voice dropping into a register that made the crystal wine glasses hum.
“I don't remember,” Vanessa stammered, her arrogant facade cracking down the middle.
“It was old and dusty, Luca. It’s probably in the attic storage with the other old seasonal decorations.”
I couldn't stay quiet any longer.
The image of what I had witnessed two hours ago flashed through my mind with horrific clarity.
“Mr. Moretti,” I spoke up, stepping forward into the light.
Luca stopped and looked at me.
“Speak, Claire.”
“Miss Bellini didn't take the cedar box to the attic, sir.”
Vanessa’s eyes flared with pure panic.
“Shut your mouth, Claire!”
I didn't flinch.
I kept my eyes on Luca.
“At five o’clock this afternoon, I was carrying clean linens to the west wing.”
“I saw Miss Bellini carrying Sarah’s cedar recipe box down the service corridor toward the private loading dock behind the garage.”
“And she wasn't just carrying that box, sir.”
“She had Gianni and two outside laborers carrying six heavy mahogany storage chests from the basement archive.”
Luca’s eyes dilated.
“What was in those six chests, Claire?”
“Those chests contained everything that belonged to Mrs. Sarah Moretti, sir.”
“Her clothes, her personal journals, her family scrapbooks, and her private jewelry cases.”
Vanessa’s face went entirely, utterly white.
Before Luca could say another word, the heavy double doors of the dining room burst open.
One of the junior catering staff stumbled into the room, looking pale and nervous as he stared at the armed men around the table.
“Mr. Moretti... excuse me, sir...”
Luca turned his head sharply.
“What is it?”
The young worker swallowed hard.
“There’s a large commercial disposal truck idling at the rear service gate, sir.”
“The driver says Miss Bellini paid him five thousand dollars in cash to collect six heavy locked crates before nine o’clock tonight.”
“He says his orders are to take them straight to the South Side industrial incinerator and burn them immediately without opening the lids.”
May you like
Lily let out a shrill, agonizing scream and clutched her father’s jacket.
“Daddy! Mom’s things! She’s going to burn Mom’s things!”
