Chapter 2 - The Yellowed Recipe Book and the Redacted Name
Hannah stood motionless against the stainless-steel prep table while the rain outside grew into a howling torrent.
The ticking of the kitchen wall clock sounded like a heavy hammer falling against lead.
"My grandmother never mentioned Ulster County," Hannah whispered, her own voice sounding foreign and distant to her ears.
"She always told me we lived in upstate rental cabins because my mother died young and we couldn't afford rent in the city."
Betty didn't answer immediately; instead, she walked over to the kitchen doors and slid the heavy brass deadbolt into place.
It was an unprecedented breach of estate rules for a kitchen to be locked from the inside during dinner service hours.
Betty moved toward the high storage cabinets behind the wine cellar entrance, dragging a heavy wooden stepstool across the stone tile floor.
She climbed up with agonizing slowness, her frail shoulders trembling under the weight of her uniform sweater.
From the very back of the highest shelf, hidden behind dusty tins of imported truffle oil, she pulled out a thick book bound in faded green oilcloth.
The edges of the cloth were frayed, stained with old cooking grease, and secured with two brittle rubber bands that snapped the moment Betty touched them.
Betty stepped down from the stool, breathing heavily, and placed the volume onto the flour-dusted prep table between them.
"This was never just a cookbook, Hannah."
"When you spend forty years cooking for wealthy families and covert government contractors, you learn that paper is the only thing that keeps you alive when memories start getting erased."
Betty opened the cracked leather binding with careful, reverent fingers.
Tucked inside the yellowed pages of pastry crusts and soup stocks were several plastic sleeves containing faded legal documents and glossy photographs.
Betty flipped past handwritten notes from 2002 and 2003 until she stopped at a page marked with a dried pressed fern.
She pulled out a small, square Polaroid photograph and pushed it across the marble counter toward Hannah.
Hannah looked down, and the breath evacuated her lungs so fast she felt dizzy.
The photograph showed a small girl sitting on a vinyl chair in a drab, windowless room, eating macaroni from a plastic yellow bowl.
The little girl had a smudge of bright red sauce on her left cheek, dark wavy hair cut unevenly with blunt scissors, and a tiny crescent-shaped dimple just below the left corner of her lower lip.
Hannah reached up with her right hand and touched that exact same dimple on her own chin.
Sitting next to the child in the photo was a woman in her late thirties, wearing a faded navy sweater and staring directly into the camera lens.
Her face was drawn, her eyes bloodshot with terrifying exhaustion, but there was no mistaking the high cheekbones and stern mouth.
It was Margaret Moore, younger, terrified, but undeniable.
"That's my grandmother," Hannah choked out, her vision blurring with sudden, inexplicable tears.
"She was thirty-eight in that picture," Betty said softly, her thumb tracing the edge of the Polaroid.
"You were barely four years old, Hannah."
"You had nightmares every single night about men in black windbreakers smashing through front doors."
"The only thing that would calm you down was sitting at my kitchen island while I stirred sweet sauce on the hot plate."
Before Hannah could ask another question, the heavy brass door handle rattled violently from the hallway outside.
Someone shoved the heavy oak door against the locked deadbolt, producing a dull, resonant thud.
"Betty? Why is the kitchen locked?"
The deep, authoritative voice belonged to Cole DeLuca, the thirty-year-old sole heir and managing director of the DeLuca family estate.
Cole had taken over the empire three years prior, following the prolonged illness and subsequent disappearance of his father, Vincent DeLuca.
Cole was known among the household staff as an exacting, emotionless man who demanded absolute perfection and utter discretion from every employee.
Betty hurried across the room, unlocked the heavy brass deadbolt, and pulled the door open.
Cole stood in the threshold, shaking water from his charcoal cashmere overcoat, his dark hair slicked back from the storm.
He took one look at Betty’s tear-stained face, then looked past her to Hannah, who was gripping the edge of the marble island like a lifeline.
"What is going on in here?" Cole asked, his sharp eyes narrowing as he stepped into the kitchen.
"Hannah dropped a tray of glassware, sir," Betty lied quickly, her voice wavering. "We were just cleaning up the shards."
"You don't lock estate doors to clean up broken glass, Betty," Cole said, his voice dropping into a dangerously calm register.
His gaze drifted down to the green oilcloth book lying open on the prep table, specifically to the glossy Polaroid resting near the flour.
Cole walked forward, completely ignoring the simmering tomato sauce, and picked up the photograph between two manicured fingers.
He glanced at the little girl, then at the younger Margaret Moore, his brow furrowing in confusion.
"Who is this?" Cole demanded. "Why is this out on the counter during dinner prep?"
Betty didn't speak; she simply turned the page of the green ledger and revealed a second photograph that had been tucked behind an intake form.
Cole looked down at the second image, and the confident, aristocratic posture he carried instantly vanished.
The color left his face so rapidly that his skin took on the grayish hue of wet cement.
The second photograph was wider, taken from across the same windowless safe-house dining room.
It showed the four-year-old Hannah holding hands with a little boy in an oversized corduroy jacket whose face was turned toward the wall.
Standing directly behind both children, with his hands resting possessively on their small shoulders, was a tall, broad-shouldered man in an expensive tailored suit.
Cole’s fingers began to tremble, mirroring Betty’s shaking hands.
"That's my father," Cole whispered, his voice cracking with an emotion Hannah had never heard from him before.
"That is Vincent DeLuca."
Cole flipped the photograph over with a sudden, frantic motion.
May you like
On the white cardboard backing of the print, scrawled in faded blue fountain pen ink, was a single, chilling sentence:
DO NOT RETURN EITHER CHILD TO THEIR FAMILIES.
