Chapter 1 - THE TRAP IN THE WHITE SIDING
The hydrangeas on Bennett Street were always too blue, too heavy, bending toward the earth as if apologizing for the soil they grew in. My mother, Deborah Monroe, spent three hours every Saturday morning trimming them with electric shears, her movements rhythmic, surgical, and entirely devoid of joy. She wore an apron with small pink embroidered roses, her silver hair coiled into a knot that never loosened, even when the July humidity made the rest of us sweat through our clothes. To anyone driving past in a Honda Civic or an SUV with travel soccer magnets on the trunk, our house looked like a magazine spread for suburban serenity. White siding that gleamed under the Ohio sun. A red front door that shouted hospitality. A mailbox she repainted every spring because "neighbors notice these things." People loved our house. They loved Deborah Monroe, the woman who taught eighth-grade English with a laminated ruler in hand and a pearl necklace resting gracefully against her collarbone. They loved her lemon bars at church fundraisers, her quiet, sympathetic nods when local mothers complained about teenage rebellion, and her unwavering dedication to raising two daughters "with grace after tragedy."
Grace. That was her favorite word. She used it the way other people used bleach—to cover stains, to burn away the evidence of something foul beneath the surface, and to leave behind a chemical scent that made your eyes water if you breathed it in too deeply. My name was Caitlyn Monroe then. I don’t use that last name anymore because Monroe belonged to the woman outside that bedroom door, the woman who stood in the hallway and laughed while the smoke tasted like copper and old carpet in my lungs. My sister, Jessica, was the golden child with blonde highlights, Lululemon leggings, a Lexus lease she couldn't afford, and the emotional depth of a clearance rack candle. She could insult me with one hand on a Starbucks cup and the other scrolling Instagram, and my mother would simply smile, tilt her head, and say, "Jessica is just expressive, Caitlyn. You know how sensitive you are."
That word—sensitive—followed me through my childhood like a tracking device. Whenever I flinched when someone raised their voice, I was sensitive. Whenever I asked why Jessica got a car while I got a used bicycle with a rusty chain, I was ungrateful. Whenever I stared out the window of our second-story bedroom, watching the neighborhood kids ride their bikes without looking over their shoulders, I was dramatic. My mother had a unique, terrifying talent for making cruelty sound clinical. She didn't yell. She didn't throw plates or slam doors like characters in trashy television dramas. She whispered. She used a low, calm, teacher-like tone that cut through your ribs like a scalpel. "You are exhausting, Caitlyn," she would say while pouring coffee into a mug with a picture of a golden retriever on it. "You drain the air out of this room. Why can't you just be easy?"
May you like
By the time I was thirteen, that question had become a physical weight pressing down on my chest. It wasn't just a psychological battle; it was a medical one engineered by a woman who needed absolute control over her environment. My mother took me to see Dr. Harrison, a pediatrician whose office smelled perpetually of stale peppermint and damp carpet. I sat on the crinkly paper of the examination table, wearing a paper gown that felt too thin against the air conditioning, while my mother spoke for me. She leaned forward in her chair, her hands folded neatly over her leather purse, and spun a narrative of a troubled, volatile child. "She lashes out, Doctor. She withdraws for days. She has these... episodes where she stares at the wall and refuses to communicate. It's like living with a stranger." I looked at a motivational poster on the wall featuring a sailboat cutting through calm water, wondering how many lies it took before adults started calling them symptoms.
Dr. Harrison didn't look at me once. He nodded, scratched notes on a yellow legal pad, and prescribed a small white pill. A week later, that pill was sitting beside my plate of chicken casserole under the warm glow of the dining room chandelier. "Take it," my mother commanded. "What is it?" I asked, my voice barely above a whisper. "Something to help you," she replied, her fork pausing halfway to her mouth. "Help me with what?" "With being less exhausting." Jessica laughed into her Diet Coke, a sharp, bubbly sound that made my ears ring. I took the pill because at thirteen, you still believe that obedience might eventually buy you love. You think that if you swallow enough bitter chemicals, if you smile hard enough when your mother fixes your collar, if you stop asking why your bedroom door doesn't have a lock on the inside, the woman who gave birth to you might look at you and see a daughter instead of a project that went wrong.
